refactor NIP-27 for simplicity -- but also include very verbose considerations and an example.

08.md

@@ -6,7 +6,7 @@ NIP-08
 Handling Mentions
 -----------------
 
-`final` `optional` `author:fiatjaf` `author:scsibug`
+`final` `unrecommended` `optional` `author:fiatjaf` `author:scsibug`
 
 This document standardizes the treatment given by clients of inline mentions of other events and pubkeys inside the content of `text_note`s.
 

27.md

@@ -4,17 +4,51 @@ NIP-27
 Text Note References
 --------------------
 
-`draft` `optional` `author:fiatjaf` `author:scsibug` `author:arthurfranca`
+`draft` `optional` `author:arthurfranca` `author:hodlbod` `author:fiatjaf`
 
-This document standardizes the treatment given by clients of inline references of other events and profiles inside the content of `text notes` (currently kinds 1 and 30023).
+This document standardizes the treatment given by clients of inline references of other events and profiles inside the `.content` of any event that has readable text in its `.content` (such as kinds 1 and 30023).
 
-Once a mention is identified by a client, for example, when an user pastes a NIP-19 nostr profile string inside the event content input field (or optionally by any other means the client may wish to support, such as selecting an user from a context menu or autocompleter), the client MUST replace it with the notation `nostr:nprofile1qqsw3dy8cpu...6x2argwghx6egsqstvg` as per NIP-21 before effectively creating the event. The client MAY add the corresponding pubkey to the `.tags` with the tag `p` if it wishes to notify mentioned user.
+When creating an event, clients should include mentions to other profiles and to other events in the middle of the `.content` using NIP-21 codes, such as `nostr:nprofile1qqsw3dy8cpu...6x2argwghx6egsqstvg`.
 
-The same process applies for referencing event IDs (using `nostr:nevent1...`), except that the client SHOULD NOT add the event id to the `.tags` with the tag `e` so to not negatively impact thread loading.
+Including [NIP-10](10.md)-style tags (`["e", <hex-id>, <relay-url>, <marker>]`) for each reference is optional, clients should do it whenever they want the profile being mentioned to be notified of the mention, or when they want the referenced event to recognize their mention as a reply.
-Because `e` tags on `text notes` are usually considered ancestor events used to build a conversarion thread (as per NIP-10), it is advised to use inline references when mentioning events and NOT adding corresponding `e` tag to the `.tags` event key.
 
-Other nostr identifiers should be referenced similarly using NIP-21 URLs inside event content (e.g. `nostr:naddr1...` for parameterized replaceable events).
+A reader client that receives an event with such `nostr:...` mentions in its `.content` can do any desired context augmentation (for example, linking to the profile or showing a preview of the mentioned event contents) it wants in the process. If turning such mentions into links, they could become internal links, NIP-21 links or direct links to web clients that will handle these references.
 
-Note that the usage of `nostr:npub1...` for profile mentions or `nostr:note1...` for event mentions is discouraged due to their lack of embedded relay recommendation.
+---
 
-A reader client that receives a `text_note` event with such `nostr:...` mentions in its `.content` CAN do any desired context augmentation (for example, linking to the profile or showing a preview of the mentioned event contents) it wants in the process. If turning such mentions into links, they could become internal links, NIP-21 links or direct links to web clients that will handle these references.
+## Example of a profile mention process
+
+Suppose a Bob is writing a note in a client that has search-and-autocomplete functionality for users that is triggered when they write the character `@`.
+
+As Bob types `"hello @mat"` the client will prompt him to autocomplete with [mattn's profile](https://gateway.nostr.com/p/2c7cc62a697ea3a7826521f3fd34f0cb273693cbe5e9310f35449f43622a5cdc), showing a picture and name.
+
+Bob presses "enter" and now he sees his typed note as `"hello @mattn"`, `@mattn` is highlighted, indicating that it is a mention. Internally, however, the event looks like this:
+
+```json
+{
+  "content": "hello nostr:nprofile1qqszclxx9f5haga8sfjjrulaxncvkfekj097t6f3pu65f86rvg49ehqj6f9dh",
+  "created_at": 1679790774,
+  "id": "f39e9b451a73d62abc5016cffdd294b1a904e2f34536a208874fe5e22bbd47cf",
+  "kind": 1,
+  "pubkey": "79be667ef9dcbbac55a06295ce870b07029bfcdb2dce28d959f2815b16f81798",
+  "sig": "f8c8bab1b90cc3d2ae1ad999e6af8af449ad8bb4edf64807386493163e29162b5852a796a8f474d6b1001cddbaac0de4392838574f5366f03cc94cf5dfb43f4d",
+  "tags": [
+    [
+      "e",
+      "2c7cc62a697ea3a7826521f3fd34f0cb273693cbe5e9310f35449f43622a5cdc"
+    ]
+  ]
+}
+```
+
+(Alternatively, the mention could have been a `nostr:npub1...` URL.)
+
+After Bob publishes this event and Carol sees it, her client will initially display the `.content` as it is, but later it will parse the `.content` and see that there is a `nostr:` URL in there, decode it, extract the public key from it (and possibly relay hints), fetch that profile from its internal database or relays, then replace the full URL with the name `@mattn`, with a link to the internal page view for that profile.
+
+## Verbose and probably unnecessary considerations
+
+- The example above was very concrete, but it doesn't mean all clients have to implement the same flow. There could be clients that do not support autocomplete at all, so they just allow users to paste raw [NIP-19](19.md) codes into the body of text, then prefix these with `nostr:` before publishing the event.
+- The flow for referencing other events is similar: a user could paste a `note1...` or `nevent1...` code and the client will turn that into a `nostr:note1...` or `nostr:nevent1...` URL. Then upon reading such references the client may show the referenced note in a preview box or something like that -- or nothing at all.
+- Other display procedures can be employed: for example, if a client that is designed for dealing with only `kind:1` text notes sees, for example, a [`kind:30023`](23.md) `nostr:naddr1...` URL reference in the `.content`, it can, for example, decide to turn that into a link to some hardcoded webapp capable of displaying such events.
+- Clients may give the user the option to include or not include tags for mentioned events or profiles. If someone wants to mention `mattn` without notifying them, but still have a nice augmentable/clickable link to their profile inside their note, they can instruct their client to _not_ create a `["p", ...]` tag for that specific mention.
+- In the same way, if someone wants to reference another note but their reference is not meant to show up along other replies to that same note, their client can choose to not include a corresponding `["e", ...]` tag for any given `nostr:nevent1...` URL inside `.content`. Clients may decide to expose these advanced functionalities to users or be more opinionated about things.